Burak Arslan

How to tell if your PPC agency is doing a good job

Cover card: How to tell if your PPC agency is doing a good job.

Burak Arslan

To tell if your PPC agency is doing a good job, I would look at three things. First, the spend on brand terms in Google Ads. Second, whether the campaigns in the account get enough conversions for the algorithm. Third, the account change logs, meaning the change history. If you want to go deeper, I would have an audit done on the account.

PPC, or pay-per-click, is advertising where you pay for each click on your ad, as in Google Ads.

The three things I check first in a PPC account

  1. Check how much of the spend in Google Ads and Apple Search Ads goes to brand terms, both the exact brand term and phrase or other brand terms. For me, if brand terms take a very high share of the spend, for example above 10%, that needs to be questioned.

  2. Check whether the campaigns get enough conversions for the algorithm. The thresholds on Google’s Target ROAS help page (checked October 2026) are at least 15 conversions in the last 30 days for Search and Shopping campaigns, and 10 conversions a day or 300 conversions in 30 days for App campaigns. Google words the first one as “at least 15 conversions in the past 30 days at the conversion tracking level.” The count is at the conversion tracking level, not per campaign. If the conversions behind a Google Ads campaign are below these levels, I look into the reason. If there is budget, I try to increase the spend, or I merge this campaign with other campaigns.

  3. Check the change history: what changes they made, and whether they make sense against performance. For me, it depends on the campaign type and the change. For example, a campaign’s bids shouldn’t be changed more than 2-3 times a week. The copy of the same ad shouldn’t be changed more often than every 7 days. Low-performing ad copy should be refreshed within two weeks, and medium-performing ad copy within a month.

Other signals in a PPC account

  1. Check the spend fluctuations in the account. One example is spending €10,000 one day and €40,000 the next. If spend changes by more than 30% a day, for me that is above the optimum. In some accounts I’ve seen the spend suddenly raised by 50%, and even 2x or 3x. That is a very unhealthy alarm level.

  2. Check what goal each campaign is running toward. For an e-commerce company, the most recommended goal in Google Ads is ROAS. On Meta it’s ROAS too. ROAS, return on ad spend, is the revenue from ads divided by the ad spend. I look at each campaign’s ROAS, its spend and its history. ROAS and spend should be balanced, and too much spend on a low-ROAS campaign is a problem.

  3. Check that the account settings, the campaign settings and the conversion tracking setup are all right. These are the detailed topics an audit of the account checks.

Reading the agency’s monthly report

When I open a PPC agency’s monthly report, I first look at the trend of the last 12 months. How are spend, revenue and ROAS developing? I also look at whether the report shows ROI. If it shows ROI, the margin is also taken into account. ROI, return on investment, is the profit after costs divided by the spend. How is ROI improving? Did they increase spend unnecessarily, or did they bring revenue in return? I look at that.

But the report also needs to show ad spend against total revenue, meaning how much of the total revenue goes to advertising. The reason is privacy: we can now miss some users’ data in Google Ads, in the ad channels, through analytics and so on. So these reports may not be telling the full truth. Maybe we’re increasing our digital marketing spend too much, or keeping it too low. Maybe revenue is growing day by day, but ad spend starts to take a very high percentage of it. That can even mean the company is losing money overall. The opposite can also happen. I look at these too.

A real case with 200 Google Ads campaigns and 30 that brought revenue

The last time I took over the account of a very large e-commerce retailer, I looked at the daily spend. The spend wasn’t actually that big, but there were around 200 campaigns in the Google Ads account, and when I saw that I knew right away something was wrong. It was the same on Meta: looking at the spend level, there were around 30 campaigns on Meta and many of them weren’t even spending money. There were also campaigns set up for other goals, not for the target.

This meant that out of around 200 Google Ads campaigns, by any measure only 30 were bringing us revenue. The other 170 brought no revenue at all. From this alone I could tell right away that the agency wasn’t doing a good job. We turned off the campaigns with low ROAS that weren’t bringing revenue and moved the budget to the top 20 campaigns. After the changes we made, ROAS improved by around 30% in the very first month.

The one question that separates a good PPC agency from a weak one

The best way to tell a good PPC agency from a weak one is to ask, in a one-to-one meeting with the agency, on the spot: what is our current spend, and what percentage of our daily revenue does our marketing spend take? There are even agencies that don’t know how much you spend per day on average. If the account manager at the agency can answer how much money you’re spending on the spot, it means they really spend time in the account and know the subject. But if they can’t answer, there may be a problem there.

Sometimes they won’t give an exact answer, because some agencies have a lot of clients. In that case you can ask other follow-up questions. For example, take the last three changes made in the account and say: I saw you made this change, why did you make it?

Is the problem the agency or the company?

The best way to tell whether the problem is the PPC agency or the company: if a company’s organic and direct revenue and traffic are going up while paid traffic and paid revenue drop sharply, then yes, we can say there’s a problem with the agency or with paid performance. But it can be the opposite: paid performance goes up while your direct traffic, organic traffic and revenue go down. Especially if the conversion rate keeps falling, in total and for the direct and organic channels, the problem may be in the company as a whole rather than in the agency.

Don’t switch agencies before you prove it

When many companies question their agency’s performance, they change the agency instead of researching the right questions and spending time on them. They go into a new process, start working with a new agency and try to find the answer by trial and error. Sometimes this method can work, but sometimes I’ve seen it lead to very big consequences. I’ve seen the new agency lose time understanding the brand, or make changes in the account that cause losses because it doesn’t know the reasons behind past decisions.

So what I definitely don’t recommend, once that suspicion comes up, is saying “let’s just try it and move to another agency” before proving it. I’ve seen many companies that did this pay for the consequences.

Getting an expert to challenge your PPC agency

If you think your PPC agency isn’t doing the right job, and you don’t have the right digital marketing experience in-house to challenge the agency, one way to solve this is to hire an expert who will challenge them. If you have that need, you can reach me. You can book my time directly with the Book a call link on my website, and we can talk through the details.

Burak Arslan, fractional head of growth for consumer brands that sell online, Berlin

Burak Arslan

Fractional head of growth for consumer brands that sell online. Running Google and Apple Ads at scale since 2012, based in Berlin.